European Exit

OMERS revamps private equity strategy

PRESENTED BY ALPHASENSE

Transacted

September 30, 2024

Happy Monday. Here’s what we’ve got today…

  • A look at OMERS’ private equity revamp

  • Plus, TPG’s deal for DirectTV (and DirecTV’s deal for Dish Network)

AlphaSense financial research

Hundreds of private equity and private credit firms now leverage AlphaSense to get an edge:

With access to 1,000+ sell-side brokers, including bulge brackets like Goldman, JPM, UBS, and Barclays, AlphaSense is a game changer for efficient private company sourcing or market research.

Dealmakers who want to go a level deeper can access AlphaSense’s proprietary Expert Transcript Library for unique, on-demand private company insights from experts in the field.

Looking for candid feedback from a former HVAC CEO before you invest? Look no further. With over 45,000 transcripts (and growing), you can niche down to find the exact information you need.

Back to status quo:

The Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System (OMERS) has decided to revamp its private equity strategy by halting direct investments in Europe and reintroducing fund investments.

Tired of fees charged by outside managers, many limited partners have prioritized fee-free co-investments and have worked to build out their in-house direct investment capabilities.

OMERS Private Equity had gone a step further. Rather than a mix of strategies, it opted to halt outside buyout allocations entirely. The platform has focused exclusively on direct investments and grown to a team of more than 50 investment professionals spread across offices in Toronto, London, New York, and Singapore.

Now, OMERS plans to pivot its European exposure by returning to investments alongside partners and through outside managers. OMERS had already shuttered its European venture operations last August.

Part of a broader restructuring of the fund's operations, the move coincides with a series of leadership changes.

Jonathan Mussellwhite, who led Europe private equity, left earlier this month. Michael Graham, OMERS' Global Head of Private Equity, is now set to retire in early 2025 and won’t be replaced after his departure.

Eric Haley, the current head of North America private equity, will assume the role of Head of Private Equity, Buyout, which will focus primarily on North America instead of its current global scope.

Concurrently, OMERS is forming a new Private Capital group to oversee various private markets activities, including venture capital, growth equity, greentech, life sciences, and European and Asia-Pacific private equity.

Private Capital will also hold a new global funds strategy and will begin making allocations to outside managers.

OMERS has not provided specific reasoning for its private equity rework, but it may feel that it's now had enough time to evaluate the global direct-only approach over the full investment lifecycle.

OMERS closed its first European direct buyout in 2011. At the time, opinions were split over whether pension fund direct investments would eventually put private equity—to some, an expensive, opaque, and commoditized service—out of business, or whether limited partners would fall flat without the institutional knowledge and talent of seasoned managers.

Reporting on the industry's reaction to OMERS’ European entrance, London's Financial News wrote: "A number of dealmakers have told us that a move to an in-house team at a pension fund didn't sound like the most attractive proposition as the pay is often lower than at their private equity brethren."

The fund’s private equity strategy manages around C$20 billion and delivered a 3.9 percent net return in 2023 against a benchmark of 9.6 percent. Performance was blamed on a challenging macro environment and weaker-than-expected EBITDA growth across the portfolio. The fund also took a valuation hit on its venture and growth-stage assets, as well as what it called "operational underperformance" in the early-stage portfolio.

10-year annualized net returns figures per each fund’s latest available reporting period

It's been a relatively turbulent decade for the fund as a whole — across all strategies, OMERS has consistently lagged behind its peers. A dismal 2020 (-2.7 percent) saw it trail other Canadian pension funds by as much as 14 percentage points and led to a request for an independent program review from its member union.

Alongside the more logical pros and cons of pension fund investment choices, there's probably also something to be said for the 'CYA' effect of outside managers. One is presumably less likely to get fired if they can pin the blame for a bad year on a basket of household buyout names vs. having to explain to constituents the decision to sink their retirement funds into a cinema business on another continent (as was the case with OMERS' acquisition of U.K.-based Vue Entertainment, purchased for £1 billion in 2013 and then handed over to lenders in 2022).

DEALS, DEALS, DEALS

DirecTV agreed to acquire Dish Network from EchoStar (Nasdaq: SATS) for $1 plus the assumption of around $9.75 billion in debt. Separately, TPG also agreed to pay $7.6 billion to buy the 70 percent stake in DirecTV it doesn't already own from AT&T.

Marsh McLennan (NYSE: MMC) agreed to acquire McGriff Insurance Services, a U.S. broker and risk management provider, for $7.75 billion in cash from TIH.

Morgan Stanley Capital Partners has hired William Blair to lead a potential sale of Sila Services, a residential HVAC and plumbing services provider that could be worth around $1.5 billion, per Reuters.

Amber Energy, backed by Elliott Investment Management, won a court-ordered auction to acquire Citgo Petroleum, a U.S. refiner with 4,300 branded retail outlets, from PDV Holding for $7.3 billion.

KinderCare Learning Companies, the Partners Group-backed provider of early childhood education, set terms for its NYSE IPO to raise up to $648 million, targeting a valuation of up to $3.09 billion.

New Mountain Capital agreed to acquire a majority stake in Salute Holdings, a provider of asset management services for data centers, from LLR Partners.

Ridgeview Partners agreed to acquire PayRange, a mobile payment technology provider for vending machines and retail checkouts.

KPS Capital Partners agreed to acquire Catalyst Acoustics Group, owner of a group of acoustic, seismic, vibration, and noise control businesses, from The Stephens Group.

DCP Capital and Hillhouse Investment are considering buying part or all of Alibaba’s (NYSE: BABA) roughly 79 percent stake in Sun Art Retail Group, a Chinese hypermarket chain with a market value of around $2.2 billion, per Bloomberg.

Kylian Mbappé acquired a stake in Loewe Technology, a German consumer electronics company.

Frasers Group offered to acquire Mulberry Group (LSE: MUL), a British handbag maker, for £83 million.

TPG agreed to acquire a minority stake in Creative Planning, an independent wealth management firm, at a $15 billion valuation.

Natra, backed by CapVest, acquired Gudrun, a Belgian chocolates and truffles manufacturer based in Lier.

Education Dynamics, a portfolio company of Renovus Capital Partners, acquired communications and brand marketing agency RW Jones and Rankin Climate, a campus climate research business.

VENTURE & EARLY-STAGE

Tech, Vertical SaaS, & Misc. Enterprise

Qodo (formerly CodiumAI), a Tel Aviv-based AI code integrity platform, raised $40 million in Series A funding led by Susa Ventures and Square Peg, with participation from Firestreak Ventures, ICON Continuity Fund, TLV Partners, and Vine Ventures.

Apono, a cloud-native access governance startup, raised $15.5 million in Series A funding led by New Era Capital Partners, with participation from Mindset Ventures, Redseed Ventures, and Silvertech Ventures.

Atlas Metrics, an ESG compliance and sustainability management platform, raised €12.2 million in Series A funding led by MMC Ventures, with participation from Cherry Ventures, b2venture, and Redstone.

Consumer & Media

HungryPanda, an Asian food delivery platform, raised $55 million in new funding led by Mars Growth Capital, with participation from Perwyn, Kinnevik, 83North, and Felix Capital.

Podeo, a Dubai-based podcast distribution platform, raised $5.4 million in Series A funding led by Oraseya Capital, with participation from Ibtikar Fund, Cedar Mundi Ventures, Samarium, iSME, and Razor Capital.

FUNDRAISING

Morgan Stanley Investment Management raised $750 million for its 1GT climate private equity fund, targeting growth-oriented investments in North American and European companies that are avoiding or removing CO2 emissions.

PARTNERSHIPS

Interested in partnering with Transacted? If you’re a financial services firm looking to connect with an engaged audience, please reach out.

Thanks for reading Transacted. Please ask your friends and colleagues to sign up. Got a tip or an idea for a story? Respond to this email, or Tweet/DM @transactedInc